STARRED REVIEW
July 2024

A Thousand Times Before

By Asha Thanki
A Thousand Times Before is a riveting magical family saga examining the indelible yet complicated bonds between mothers and daughters while transporting readers through major moments in 20th-century Indian history.
Share this Article:

Asha Thanki’s magical debut, A Thousand Times Before, is a mesmerizing multigenerational chronicle about a remarkable family of Indian women bound to one another by more than blood.

In present-day Brooklyn, Ayukta is ready to reveal to her wife, Nadya, why she has been so ambivalent about starting a family, a decision made difficult for Ayukta due to an extraordinary family heirloom: a tapestry embroidered with images of the women in her family spanning back generations. When a mother sews her daughter onto the tapestry, it unlocks the ability for the daughter to relive the memories of all the women depicted there. What’s more, each custodian of the tapestry is also granted the power to make their heart’s desires reality. 

To convince Nadya of the truth behind her wild claims, Ayukta relates the stories of the women in her family as she herself has experienced them through the tapestry. She starts with her grandmother Amla in Karachi, before the Partition of India in 1947, continuing on to her mother Arni’s girlhood in Gujarat where she was involved in the 1974 student protests against the government. With each woman, Ayukta shares both the triumphs and the tragedies that the tapestry’s double-edged powers afforded them, all while grappling with her own dilemma of whether this inheritance is a burden or a blessing.

A Thousand Times Before is a riveting family saga as well as a tender examination of the indelible yet complicated bonds between mothers and daughters. Thanki transports readers through major moments in 20th-century Indian history, making them accessible and personal via her cast of charismatic characters, elegant prose and spellbinding storytelling. Despite the otherworldly elements woven into the narrative, the themes of love, grief and family that Thanki so thoughtfully develops easily ground the novel in reality, making for an emotionally charged and memorable reading experience.

Trending Reviews

Get the Book

Sign Up

Stay on top of new releases: Sign up for our newsletter to receive reading recommendations in your favorite genres.